Business Law An Introduction OUCOME3 题+答案.docx
- 文档编号:7664379
- 上传时间:2023-01-25
- 格式:DOCX
- 页数:11
- 大小:19.40KB
Business Law An Introduction OUCOME3 题+答案.docx
《Business Law An Introduction OUCOME3 题+答案.docx》由会员分享,可在线阅读,更多相关《Business Law An Introduction OUCOME3 题+答案.docx(11页珍藏版)》请在冰豆网上搜索。
BusinessLawAnIntroductionOUCOME3题+答案
Business Law:
An Introduction OUCOME3(带A4)
CaseStudy1
Question1
ThemainbusinessorganisationsrecognisedbyScotsLaware:
.
soletrader
.
partnerships
.
limitedpartnerships
.
limitedliabilitypartnerships
.
privatecompanies
.
publiccompanies
Question2
GiventhefactthatLisaisrunningaverysmallbusiness,itwillalmostbecertainlyrunasasole
traderenterprise.Thereistheveryremotepossibility—anditisveryremote—thatasmall
businesscouldberunasasinglememberprivatecompanyintermsoftheCompanies(Single
MemberPrivateLimitedCompanies)Regulations1992.Suchaprivatecompanyislimitedby
sharesorbyguaranteeandneedonlyhaveonemember.Nowhere,however,doesitmention
thatthebusinessislimitedbysharesorbyguaranteeandwewould,therefore,assumethatithas
thecharacterofasoletrader.
Question3
Theadvantagesofasoletraderbusinessare:
1
ItisthesimplestformofbusinessorganisationrecognisedbyScotsLaw.
2
Asoletraderistoallintentsandpurposestoberegardedasaself-employedperson.In
otherwords,nodifferenceismadebetweenthesoletraderandhisorherbusiness;they
arelegallyindistinguishable.
3Verybasiclegalrequirementstocomplywithiesubmissionofincometaxreturnstothe
InlandRevenueandthedisclosurerequirementsoftheBusinessNamesAct1985.
4Totalcontroloverhisorherbusinessanddoesnothavetotakeintoaccounttheopinions
ofanyshareholders,membersorpartners.
Thedisadvantagesofasoletraderbusinessare:
1Ifthebusinessfails,thesoletraderissaidtohaveunlimitedliabilityforanydebtsor
obligationsowedtothirdparties.
2Asoletradermayfinditdifficulttofundanexpansionofthebusinessbecauseshe/he
cannotoffersharestootherpartiesinordertoraisefunds.
3
Inanycase,abusinessexpansionrequiringamajorinjectionofcapitalmightentailaloss
ofcontroloverthebusinessbecausenewpartners,shareholdersormemberswhoarea
sourceofnewfinancewillalmostcertainlydemandasayintherunningofthebusiness.
4
Theinclusionofnewpartners,membersorshareholderswouldforceachangeinthe
natureofthebusinessoperationbyconvertingitintoapartnershiporsomeotherformof
corporatebody(public/privatecompaniesoralimitedliabilitypartnership).
CaseStudy2
【】
Question1
Therearemanydifferencesbetweenatraditionalpartnershipandalimitedliabilitypartnership
(LLP),butcandidatesshouldbeabletopinpointthefollowingcharacteristicsofbothtypesof
businessorganisationfromthetablebelow:
PartnershipLimitedliabilitypartnership
UnincorporatedbusinessCorporatebody
NoneedtoberegisteredwithRegistrarof
Companiesandnoneedtosupplyformal
documents
MustberegisteredwiththeRegistrarof
Companiesandcertaindocumentsmustbe
supplied
RegulatedbyPartnershipAct1890(unlessthe
partnersagreeotherwise)
RegulatedbytheLimitedLiability
PartnershipsAct2000
Partnershaveunlimitedliabilityinrespectof
partnershipdebts/liabilitiesietheyarejointly
andseverallyliableandcanbepursuedtotheir
lastpenny
Membersenjoylimitedliabilityinrespectof
LLPdebts/liabilitiesietheywillonlybe
liabletotheextentoftheirstakeinthe
business
PracticeNote
Itwouldbehighlyadvisabletoconcentrateonthedifferencesbetweenatraditionalpartnership
andanLLPwhenintroducingcandidatestothisareaofthecourse.
Question2
Currently,manytraditionalpartnershipshavesoughtLLPstatusbecauseoftheperceived
benefitsoflimitedliabilityforthemembersofanLLP—evenifthisdoesrepresentalossof
privacyandgreaterexternalregulationforthemembersieregistrationwiththeRegistrarof
Companiesandtougherauditingrequirements.
Question3
Thelegalrelationshipbetweenpartnersinafirmisclassifiedasafiduciaryrelationshipiea
relationshipoftrust.Partnersareagentsoftheirfellowpartnersandalsoofthefirmitself.
Candidatesshouldcitethefollowingcasewhichexemplifiesthenatureofthefiduciary
relationshipbetweenpartners:
.
PillansBrothersvPillans[1908]
Thelegalrelationshipbetweenamemberandalimitedliabilitypartnershipwillalsobe
classifiedasafiduciaryrelationship.Section6oftheLimitedLiabilityPartnershipsAct2000
statesthatthemembersofanLLParetoberegardedastheagentsofthebusinessanditisa
generalruleofthelawofagencythatanagent(themember)mustalwaysactinthebest
interestsofhisprincipal(theLLP).Itisimportanttobearinmindthatamemberisnotanagent
ofhisfellowmembers.
CaseStudy3
Question1
Acompany’sobjectsclauseisfoundinitsMemorandumofAssociation.Theobjectsclausesets
outthepurposeofthecompanyusuallyintheformofalist(sometimesaverylonglist)ofthe
variouscommercialandbusinessactivitiesthatitislikelytoundertake.Beforethereforms
introducedbytheCompaniesAct1989,companiescouldnotenterintocertaincontractswith
thirdpartiesunlesssuchacommercialtransactionwaslistedintheobjectsclause.Suchan
unauthorisedcontractwasvoidbyreasonofthecompany’slackofcapacitytoentersuchan
agreementinthefirstplaceandignoranceofthecontentsoftheobjectsclauseonthepartofthe
thirdpartywasnodefence.Nowadays,manycompanieswillhavestraightforwardobjects
clauseswhichallowthemtoenterintoanytypeofbusinessorcommercialtransaction
whatsoever.
Question2
Noisthesimpleanswer.MacGregordoesnothavelegaljustificationforitswithdrawalfrom
thecontractwithConstructit.MacGregorisattemptingtorelyontheoldultraviresrule.Asa
resultofreformsintroducedbytheCompaniesAct1989,Section35oftheCompaniesAct1985
nowstatesthateverycontractisenforceableagainstthecompany.Noactdonebyacompany
maybequestionedbythefactthatitwasbeyonditslegalcapacityasstatedinitsobjectsclause
intheMemorandumofAssociation.Section35Bofthe1985Actgoesontosaythatthereisno
necessityforathirdpartytocheckthataproposedcontractiswithinthepowersofthecompany
aspertheMemorandumofAssociation.Furthermore,Section3AoftheCompaniesAct1985
nowpermitsacompanytohaveasimplifiedobjectsclausewhichmeansacompanycanenter
intopracticallyanycontractwhatsoeverwiththirdparties.
Insituationswherethirdpartiesdealingwiththecompanyhavefailedtoactingoodfaithand
wheretheDirectorshaveexceededtheirauthority,Section35A:
CompaniesAct1985raisesthe
possibilitythatsuchanultravirescontractmaybedeclaredvoidablebythecompany.Inother
words,theultraviresrulecomesbacktohauntthirdpartiesdealingwiththecompanywhen
theyactinbadfaith—butnotinthiscasestudy.
Candidatesshouldcitethefollowingcasewhichemphasisestheharshnessoftheoldultravires
rule:
.
AshburyRailwayCarriage&IronCovRiche[1875]
Question3
CandidatesmustreferencetheiranswertoSection14oftheCompaniesAct1985iethebinding
contractualnatureoftheMemorandumofAssociationandtheArticlesofAssociation.The
shareholderswillhavetoestablishwhethertheyareentitledtoreceivebonusesintermsofthe
company’sArticlesofAssociation.Ifso,theycanraiseanactionagainstthecompanyinterms
ofSection14toforcepaymentofdividends.Ifthepaymentofbonusesispurelydiscretionary,
thecompanymaywellhavetherighttosuspendpaymentthisyear.
Candidatesshouldbeabletociteatleastoneofthefollowingexamplesfromcaselawin
supportoftheiranswerwhichdemonstratethattherelationshipbetweenacompanyandits
membersandbetweenthemembersthemselvesiscontractualinnatureasperSection14ofthe
CompaniesAct1985:
.
EleyvPositiveLifeAssuranceCoLtd[1876]
.
HickmanvKentorRomneyMarshSheepBreeders’Association[1915]
.
RayfieldvHands[1960]
.
WoodvOdessaWaterworksCo[1889]
CaseStudy4
Question1
Therearenumerousdifferencesbetweenprivateandpubliccompanies.Itisoftenusefultogive
candidatesalistofthedifferentcharacteristicsofbothorganisationswherebytheyareableto
compareandcontrast.Candidatesareonlybeingaskedtolistthreedifferencesbetweena
privatecompanyandapubliccompanyfromthetwolistssetoutbelowandthereisplentyto
choosefrom.
Themaincharacteristicsofaprivatelimitedcompanyare:
1
Companynamemustendin“limited”or“ltd”.
2
TheArticlesofAssociationofaprivatelimitedcompanymayprovideforarightofpreemption
sothatwhenamemberwishestosellortotransferownershipofhisshareshe
mustfirstofferthemtoexistingmembers.
3Thereisnominimumcapitalrequirement.
4Thesharesinaprivatelimitedcompanycannotbetradedorlistedonthestockexchange.
5Onlyonedirectorisrequired.
6IntermsoftheCompanies(SingleMemberPrivateLimitedCompanies)Regulations
1992,aprivatecompanylimitedbysharesorbyguaranteeneedonlyhaveonemember.
7Thereisnoupperagelimitfordirectors.
8Auditedaccountsmustbeproducedwithin10monthsoftheendofthefinancialyear.
9TradingcanstartassoonasaCertificateofIncorporationisobtained.
Themaincharacteristicsofapubliclimitedcompanyare:
1Thecompanynamemustendin“publiclimitedcompany”or“plc”.
2Membersmustbefreetotransfertheirsharesastheyplease.
3Apubliccompanymusthaveminimumissuedsharecapitalofatleast£50,000.
4Sharescanbe
- 配套讲稿:
如PPT文件的首页显示word图标,表示该PPT已包含配套word讲稿。双击word图标可打开word文档。
- 特殊限制:
部分文档作品中含有的国旗、国徽等图片,仅作为作品整体效果示例展示,禁止商用。设计者仅对作品中独创性部分享有著作权。
- 关 键 词:
- Business Law An Introduction OUCOME3 题+答案 答案