Filed62413PvJenningsCA41doc.docx
- 文档编号:6892790
- 上传时间:2023-01-12
- 格式:DOCX
- 页数:14
- 大小:30.32KB
Filed62413PvJenningsCA41doc.docx
《Filed62413PvJenningsCA41doc.docx》由会员分享,可在线阅读,更多相关《Filed62413PvJenningsCA41doc.docx(14页珍藏版)》请在冰豆网上搜索。
Filed62413PvJenningsCA41doc
Filed6/24/13P.v.JenningsCA4/1
NOTTOBEPUBLISHEDINOFFICIALREPORTS
CaliforniaRulesofCourt,rule8.1115(a),prohibitscourtsandpartiesfromcitingorrelyingonopinionsnotcertifiedforpublicationororderedpublished,exceptasspecifiedbyrule8.1115(b).Thisopinionhasnotbeencertifiedforpublicationororderedpublishedforpurposesofrule8.1115.
COURTOFAPPEAL,FOURTHAPPELLATEDISTRICT
DIVISIONONE
STATEOFCALIFORNIA
THEPEOPLE,
PlaintiffandRespondent,
v.
THOMASDEANJENNINGS,
DefendantandAppellant.
D061872
(Super.Ct.No.SCD229068
Super.Ct.No.SCD236226)
APPEALfromajudgmentoftheSuperiorCourtofSanDiegoCounty,RichardS.WhitneyandJeffreyF.Fraser,Judges.Affirmedasmodifiedandremandedwithdirections.
RobertBooher,underappointmentbytheCourtofAppeal,forDefendantandAppellant.
KamalaD.Harris,AttorneyGeneral,DaneR.Gillette,ChiefAssistantAttorneyGeneral,JulieL.Garland,AssistantAttorneyGeneral,LiliaE.GarciaandQuisteenS.Shum,DeputyAttorneysGeneral.
INTRODUCTION
ThisappealbyThomasDeanJennings,whopreviouslywasconvictedin2002offourcountsofresidentialburglarythatqualifiedasstrikesundertheThreeStrikeslaw,involvestwonewcriminalcases(SCD229068&SCD236226)andsevennewfelonieshecommittedin2010duringfourmoreresidentialburglaries.
SCD229068
OnSeptember7,2011,inSCD229068,ajuryfoundJenningsguiltyofonecountofburglaryofaninhabiteddwelling(Pen.Code,§§459&460;undesignatedstatutoryreferenceswillbetothePenalCodeunlessotherwisespecified).Onthatsamedate,inabifurcatedproceedinginthatcase,Jenningsadmitted
(1)afirstprisonpriorconvictionallegation(§§667.5,subd.(b)&668)alleginghehadservedaprisontermbasedonhisfour2002priorresidentialburglaryoffenses;
(2)afirstseriousfelonypriorconvictionallegationbasedonthosefouroffenses(§§667,subd.(a)
(1),668&1192.7,subd.(c));and(3)anallegationthatthosefouroffenseswerepriorstrikeconvictionswithinthemeaningoftheThreeStrikeslaw(§667,subds.(b)-(i),668&1170.12).
SCD236226
OnFebruary29,2012,inSCD236226,ajuryfoundJenningsguiltyofthreecountsofburglaryofaninhabiteddwellinghouse(counts1,4&6:
§§459&460),onecountofunlawfultakingofavehicle(count2:
Veh.Code,§10851,subd.(a)),andthreecountsofgrandtheftofpersonalproperty(counts3,5&7:
§§484,subd.(a),487,subd.(a)&488).Onthatsamedate,Jenningsadmittedafirstprisonpriorconvictionallegation(§§667.5,subd.(b)&668)andanallegationthathisfour2002residentialburglaryoffenseswerepriorstrikeconvictionswithinthemeaningoftheThreeStrikeslaw(§§667,subds.(b)-(i),668&1170.12).
Sentencing(BothCases)
Atthecombinedsentencinghearinginbothcases,heldonApril13,2012,thecourtdeniedJennings'sRomeromotiontostrikethreeofhisfourpriorstrikes,andsentencedhimtoanaggregateprisontermof100yearstolifeplusfiveyears.
Specifically,inSCD236226,thecourtsentencedJenningstoconsecutive25-year-to-lifetermsforeachofthethreeresidentialburglaryconvictions,plusconcurrent25-year-to-lifetermsforeachofthegrandtheftconvictionsandforthetakingofavehicleconviction,andstrucktheprisonpriorallegation.InSCD229068,thecourtsentencedJenningsto25yearstolife─consecutivetothesentenceimposedinSCD236226─forhisresidentialburglaryconviction,plusaconsecutivefive-yeartermforthetruefindingontheseriousfelonypriorconvictionallegation,andstrucktheprisonpriorallegation.
ContentionsonAppeal
Inhisappeal,Jenningsraisesthreecontentions.First,hecontendshistrialcounselprovidedconstitutionallyineffectiveassistanceby
(1)failingatthesentencinghearingtodiscussPeoplev.Garcia(1999)20Cal.4th490(Garcia)andarguethatthreeofhisfour2002priorstrikeconvictionsshouldbestrickenbecausetheyaroseoutofasingleperiodofaberrantconductand
(2)failingtoprovidethecourtatsentencingwithareporter'stranscriptofthe2002hearingatwhichhewassentencedforthosepriorstrikeconvictionsbecausethetranscriptwouldhaveshownthatthecourtatthatpriorsentencinghearingfound,asamitigatingfactor,thathecommittedthefourunderlyingresidentialburglariesduringasingleperiodofaberrantconduct
Second,Jenningsclaimsthecourterredbynotstayingundersection654theexecutionofthesentencesitimposedincaseNo.SCD236226forthethreegrandtheftconvictionsandfortheconvictionofunlawfullytakingordrivingofavehicle.
Last,hecontendsthecourtviolatedhisSixthAmendmentrighttohaveeachelementofthechargedoffensesprovenbeyondareasonabledoubt,aswellashisFourteenthAmendmentrighttodueprocess,whenitinstructedthejuryinSCD236226withCALCRIMNo.376regardingthepossessionofrecentlystolenpropertyasevidenceofacrime.
WemodifythejudgmenttostaytheexecutionofthesentencesthecourtimposedinSCD236226forJennings'sthreegrandtheftconvictionsandhisconvictionofunlawfullytakingavehicle.Inallotherrespects,weaffirmthejudgmentandremandthematterwithdirections.
FACTUALBACKGROUND
A.SCD229068
Ataround1:
20a.m.onAugust9,2010,someonecalledSanDiegoPoliceDetectiveBlaineFergusononhiscellphoneandinformedthedetectivehebelievedaburglarywouldoccurat4577thAvenueinImperialBeachsometimelaterthatday.ThecallertoldDetectiveFergusonthenicknameoftheindividualwhowasgoingtocommittheburglary.
Laterthatmorning,DetectiveFergusoncontactedaninvestigativedetectiveassignedtotheImperialBeachareaandlearnedthatthedetectivedidnothaveenoughstafftoconductsurveillance.WithseveralotherofficersandtheairsupportunitoftheSanDiegoPoliceDepartment,DetectiveFergusonsetupsurveillancealong7thAvenue.
Shortly·afterwards,thepolicespottedagreencarwithheavilyoxidizedpaintdrivingslowlythroughtheneighborhood.Thecardrovepastthehouseat4577thAvenue,stoppedatanadjacentintersection,andletapassengeroutofthecar.Thepassengerwalkedbacktothehouseandenteredit.Meanwhile,thecarwithitstworemainingoccupantsdroveoffandparkedafewblocksaway.
Afteraperiodoftime,thegreencarreturnedtothehousethatwasbeingburglarized.Thetwopeoplewhohadbeeninthecarandthepersonwhohadenteredthehouseloadeditemstakenfromthehouseinthecar.ThethreesuspectsleftthehouseinthegreencaranddrovenorthboundonSilverStrandWay.Thepolicefollowedthegreencarinunmarkedvehiclesuntiltheycouldinitiateatrafficstop.
Whenthepoliceintheirmarkedvehiclesactivatedtheiroverheadlightsandsirensandtriedtostopthegreencar,thegreencarmadeaU-turnanddrovesouthboundonSilverStrandWay.Thegreencareventuallycrashedintotrafficatanintersectionnearthenavalamphibiousbase.Therear-seatpassenger,lateridentifiedasJennings,jumpedoutofthegreencarandran.DetectiveFergusongotoutofhiscarandchasedJennings.Jenningstriedtoclimboverthesecurityfenceofthenavalbase,buthebecameentangledonthebarbedstanchionsatthetopofthefence.Ashewashangingupsidedownonthenavalbasesideofthefence,heremovedhispantsandfelltotheground.Wearingonlyhisshirtandunderwear,hegotupandranthroughthebase.Jennings'spants,whichcontainedhiswalletandevidenceofhisidentity,werelaterrecovered.
Jenningseventuallyhidinsideawarehouseonthebase.Thepoliceevacuatedmilitarypersonneloutofthewarehouse,wentinside,andarrestedhim.
RyanTraver,wholivedinthehouseat4577thStreet,identifiedthepropertyfoundinthegreencarashis.Thepropertyincludedaflatscreentelevision,DVD's,tools,abackpackfilledwithpennies,anunderwatercamera,andwatches.TraverdidnotknowJenningsortheothersuspects,andhedidnotgivethempermissiontoenterhishomeortakehisbelongings.
B.SCD236226
6467BluefieldPlace,SanDiego
StuartWilliamslivedwithhismother,JoyWinter,inahouseat6467BluefieldPlaceinSanDiego.OnJune25,2010,Williamsleftthehouseatabout11:
00a.m.Hewasthelastpersontoleavethehouse.
WhenWilliamsreturnedhomeafter1:
00p.m.thatday,everythinginsidethehousewasintotaldisarray.Plantswereknockedover,paperswerescatteredeverywhere,drawershadbeenpulledoutandemptied,andthebathroomcupboardalsohadbeenemptied.Winter'sAudistationwagonthathadbeenparkedinthegaragewasmissing,asweretheduplicatecarkeysfortheAudiandWinter'sJaguar,atelevision,andseveralhundreddollars'worthofstamps.Insidehisbedroom,Williamsnoticedthatacomputer,alaptop,andhispassportweremissing,andpapershadbeensiftedthrough.Hecalledhismotherandthepolice.
Winter,whowaspreparingforatriptoAfrica,noticedthatheridentification,creditcards,currentpassport,sixexpiredpassports,andavisaweregone.Herjewelryand$300incashalsoweremissing.
WinterandWilliamsdidnotknowJenningsanddidnotgiveanyonepermissiontotaketheAudioranyoftheirotherbelongingsfromtheirhome.
ThatnightthepolicelocatedtheAudinearthe6000blockofFederalBoulevard.WhenWintersawhercarthenextday,shenoticedthattheroofonthebackhadbeentornapartandatirehadbeenremoved.
JohnBarker,Winter'sneighbor,wasworkinginhisfrontyardaround11:
00a.m.onJune25,2010,whentwoyoungWhitemalesapproachedhimandhandedhimaflierforlandscapeservices.Theycontinue
- 配套讲稿:
如PPT文件的首页显示word图标,表示该PPT已包含配套word讲稿。双击word图标可打开word文档。
- 特殊限制:
部分文档作品中含有的国旗、国徽等图片,仅作为作品整体效果示例展示,禁止商用。设计者仅对作品中独创性部分享有著作权。
- 关 键 词:
- Filed62413PvJenningsCA41doc