比较教育学重点.docx
- 文档编号:4033140
- 上传时间:2022-11-27
- 格式:DOCX
- 页数:11
- 大小:64.31KB
比较教育学重点.docx
《比较教育学重点.docx》由会员分享,可在线阅读,更多相关《比较教育学重点.docx(11页珍藏版)》请在冰豆网上搜索。
比较教育学重点
Chapter2MajorTheoriesinComparativeEducation
1.Introduction
A.ModernistPerspectives
Structural-functionalismvs.Marxism
ØSimilarities:
a)StemfromcommonantecedentsintheWesternEnlightenmentEra
ØDifferences:
Structural-functionalism:
envisions展望consensus一致andequilibrium均衡tobehallmarks印记ofsocialintercourse交流andhumanprogress,andseesstability稳定性asnaturalanddesirabl令人满意的e.
Marxism:
questionsthepossibilityofconsensus,critiquetheauthenticity真实性ofapparentconsensus,andassertthatconflictratherthanstabilityistheoverriding高于一切的catalystforsocialchange.
B.PostmodernistandPoststructuralistPerspectives
ØDenyrationalistexplanations,challengeandquestionmodernization
ØQuestionthepossibilityof“masternarratives”大叙事orencompassingtheoreticalarguments
ØFocusonotherwisemarginalized边缘化alternativeperspectives
ØRejectpredictabilityasgoalfortheory
2.Structural-functionalism
ØStabilityandequilibrium,beingcentralwithinthestructural-functionalistanalysis,reflectthetheory’sidentityasaconsensusperspective.
A.WhatisStructural-functionalism
ØThreeMajorCharacteristicsofStructural-functionalism
a)Unitary统一的:
Structural-functionalism’sidentityasaconsensustheoryisbuiltontheconvictionthatsocietyisunitaryandthatthebuildingandpreservationofagreementisthepreferredandmostpowerfulsocialforce.
b)Coherence连贯性:
notonlyasaunituntoitselfbutalsointermsoftherelationshipsthatexistamongitsvariouselements.Socialinstitutionsarenotjustacollectiveofpeople,but,rather,anentity实体havingclearpurposeandpotentialtofulfillsocialneeds,especiallysocialsolidarity.
c)Stability:
workingtowardsharmonyanditsownself-preservation,anditsownrelianceonthemotionofequilibriumasafundamentaltraitofsociety,andsocialprogressispredictablylinear.
ØStructural-functionalismisaframeworkforbuildingtheorythatseessocietyasacomplexsystemwhosepartsworktogethertopromotesolidarityandstability.Thisapproachlooksatsocietythroughamacro-levelorientation,whichisabroadfocusonthesocialstructuresthatshapesocietyasawhole,andbelievesthatsocietyhasevolvedlikeorganisms.
B.Criticism
Structural-functionalistthoughtdoesnotitselfarticulate使相互连贯amodelofchangebecauseitsproponentsviewchangeasaconsequenceofsocietalresponsetoimbalancesorimperfections,oradjustmentsorrefinements改良品ofexistingsocialconditions,ratherthanaschangesinthesocialorder.
C.ApplyonEducationalPractice
a)Schoolsareimportantcontributorstothemaintenanceofequilibrium
b)Classroomsarespaceswhereresponsibleandproductivecitizensareformed
c)Teachersconveyandreinforcevaluesthatnurturestudents’societalparticipationinlinewithmainstreamsocialvaluesratherthaninoppositiontothosevalues.
d)Literacyisoneamongmanyskillsthatcontributestoeconomicandsocialproductivity,andthiskeepswiththemaintenanceofstatusquowithaneyeonthenurturanceofastablesocialorder.
第一个理论记住几个关键词:
stability,coherence,equilibrium,unity,并理解好这几个词,然后看看教育方面的应用就差不多了。
3.Modernization
A.WhatisModernizationTheory?
ØHumannatureisavariable可变的ratherthanaconstantintermsoftheprospectforchange;thisviewofhumannatureasvariable,malleable,可塑的andthereforesubjecttorefinementiskey.
ØModernizationtheorytiessocietaldevelopmenttothelevelofindividualperson,and,so,providesarationalefortheroleofeducationwithinsocietiesseekingtomodernize.Developmentbecomesafunctionoftheattainmentofmodernattitudesattheindividuallevel;society’smodernizationbecomesaproductofthepercolationoftheseattitudesthroughoutanexpandingcircleofitsindividualmembers.
ØProgressissequential连续的andpossessingmomentum.势头Humanprogressisgovernedinpartbyanaturalmotivetowardsachievement.
ØModernstatesarewealthierandmorepowerful,andthattheircitizensarefreertoenjoyahigherstandardofliving.(urbanization,industrialization,Newtechnologyisamajorsourceofsocialchange,buttheydon’tchangesocietiesbyitself.)
ØHumanagencycontrolsthespeedandseverityofmodernization.
Summary:
adaptationofstructural-functionalism,generallypredictableandmanageable,aprescriptionofchange,educationofindividuals
B.Criticism
ØTheideological意识形态的andculturalbiasesinherentinthetheory
a)Westernbiases:
modernization≠westernization
b)Traditionalvalues:
Modernizationvaluesmightnotbeincompatible不相容的withtraditionalones.
ØQuestiontheassumptionthattheattainmentofmodernvaluesattheindividuallevelwillinfacttranslateintoasociety-widephenomenonatlevelsthatarecapableofgeneratingandsustainingnationaldevelopment.
C.ModernizationTheoryuponTeachers
ØConnectsindividualstudents’progresswiththesociety’sgeneralreadinessforthefuture
ØSchools—well-preparedcitizensformodernization
ØModerninstitutionsinstilled逐渐灌输inindividuals,encouragingtheadoptionofmodernbehaviorsamongcitizens
基本理论都要知道,批判的观点要知道,教育的观点要知道,基本上这里的都挺重要的。
4.HumanCapitalFormationTheory人力资本构造理论
A.Sociology社会学Concept
ØThetermcapitalpertains从属tobothmaterialandotherresourcesthatcontributetotheaccumulationofwealthbyindividualsorbysocieties.
ØInvestmentsintheacquisition获得ofgoodswillreap收获returns.
ØEducation’spotentialasaspur鼓舞forinvestments
B.HumanCapitalFormationTheoryandEducation
ØAdoptsstructural-functionalism’soverarching首要的commitments,reflectingadirectandfunctionalrelationshipbetweeneducationanddevelopment
ØNation-stateasadiscrete离散的andvitalfocusofanalysis,generallyattributingeconomicunder-developmenttofactorswithinthesocietyinquestion.
ØPursuemeasurability可测量性byseekingtoaccountforallfactorsthatmightcontributetoeconomicgrowth—hereagainpointingtostructural-functionalismtowardsprediction,causality因果关系,andthemanageabilityofsocietyanditsactivities.
ØInvestmentandeducationthattheyenvision,intheirmodernistandwesternizedviewofprogressanddevelopment,andintheirfocusonthesocietyasthefunctionalandharmoniouscontextfortheoreticalanalysisandpolicyaction.
A的内容可以不看,只是基础,B的内容才是重点。
5.Marxism
A.BasicSociologicalPerspectivesofMarxism
ØScientificcommunism科学社会主义/Historicalmaterialism历史唯物主义
ØChangeasadialogueorinteractionbetweentwoentities实体
ØSubstructureofdifferentsocialclassesorsociallevels—strata
Conflict
Bourgeoisie资产阶级—ExploitingClasses剥削阶级—Occupyworkers
Proletariat无产阶级—Exploitedpositions—BeingcontrolledbyBourgeoisie
DifferencesbetweenMarxismandStructural-functionalism:
Whilebothacknowledgethatsocialinstitutionsandmechanismsdoworktowardtheendofpreservingsociety,thestructural-functionalismseesthistendencyasfundamentallydesirable令人满意的andjust.Marxist,incontrast,critiquethesameargumentinfavorofsocietalstabilityasunfairifinequitiesaremaintainedamongsociety’ssubstrata.下层
ØEstrangementandAlienationPerspectives疏远和异化的角度
Therefore,raisingconsciousnessaboutunfairconditionsarenecessaryinordertoreplacefeelingsofpowerlessnesswithasenseofcapacityandagencyregardingone’sowncircumstances.
Summary:
Marxcontended满足thatthelatentconflictbetweenadvantagedanddisadvantagedclasseswouldinevitablybecomeovert明显的.Thehistoryofhumanexperiencehasexhibitedunendingconflictbetweenoppressorsandtheoppressed.Theseconflictsareresolvedthroughdominantclassreplacingitspredecessor前任torenewoppositionatahigherlevel,withoppressiontakingnewforms.
B.MarxismandEducation
ØContext-centeredanalysis:
problemsrelatedtofairdistributionsofhumanoutputsareaddressedbyknowledgegainedthroughasciencerootedinunderstandingthenatureofhumancommunicationandagreementratherthanonthepredictionandcontrolofnaturalenvironments.
ØSchoolinginMarxistcountriesisthevehiclesfordialectical辩证的progressfromacapitalistsocietytothecommunistsociety.
ØSupportspecializedindustrialandtechnicaleducationascatalysts催化剂forhumanprogresswhileeschewing避免formsofeducationthatweretoonarrowtoenablethoughtfulappraisalsofsocialcircumstances.
ØAcurriculumbasedonthethreeaimsofmentaleducation,physicaleducation,andtechnologicallearning.
ØCorrespondence相当性Theory:
thesystemofcounterpartsbetweenschoolsandworkplaces.ThistheoryispessimisticaboutaspectsthatMertonhadcharacterizedasbenign,stabilizingforces—the“latent”functionsofschool,suchaspassivecompliancewiththeverticalpowerstructuresofauthority,strictschedules,etc.
C.Criticism
ØWesternbias—focusonthehistoryofmaterialismintheEuropeancontextanddidnotgrapplewiththeissueofunderdevelopment
ØNotallsocietiesreflectthepresenceofsortsofclassstructuresMarxisttheoriesdescribe
D.SummaryofMarxistPerspectives
Adherents追随者ofMarxisttheoryacknowledgetheexistenceofconsensusandtheappearanceofstabilitybutarepessimisticaboutthedegreetowhichconsensusisgenuine真实的.ForMarx,classstructureswithinsocietyareharmoniousinappearance,andsocialchangeoccurswhenlatent潜在的conflictbetweenexploitedworkingorproletariatclassesandcapitalbourgeoisclassesbecomeovert.Marxisttheoryismorethananideologicalimpetus动力forpoliticalenterprisesandremainsapotent有效的conflict-orientedcounterbalance平衡力totheprevailing盛行consensusperspectives.Inresponsetocontemporarycallsformoreschoolstoproduceabetter-preparedworkforce,neo-Marxistthinkerscontinuetopressthequestion,“Whoseeconomyisitthattheschoolmustbe
- 配套讲稿:
如PPT文件的首页显示word图标,表示该PPT已包含配套word讲稿。双击word图标可打开word文档。
- 特殊限制:
部分文档作品中含有的国旗、国徽等图片,仅作为作品整体效果示例展示,禁止商用。设计者仅对作品中独创性部分享有著作权。
- 关 键 词:
- 比较 教育学 重点