NewHeritageDoll.docx
- 文档编号:29766260
- 上传时间:2023-07-26
- 格式:DOCX
- 页数:8
- 大小:25.60KB
NewHeritageDoll.docx
《NewHeritageDoll.docx》由会员分享,可在线阅读,更多相关《NewHeritageDoll.docx(8页珍藏版)》请在冰豆网上搜索。
NewHeritageDoll
NewHeritageDoll
NewHeritageDollCompany:
CapitalBudgeting
MGT6060
20September2011
Overview
TwobusinessproposalsfromtheProductiondivisionoftheNewHeritageDollCompanyarebeingconsideredforsubmissiontothecapitalbudgetingcommittee.Onlyoneproposalwillbesubmitted.Theproposalsare:
MatchMyDollClothingLineExpansionandDesignYourOwnDoll.
Asystematicprocesswillbeusedtodeterminewhichproposaltorecommend.CriteriaInclude:
1.Comparisonofthebusinesscases
2.NPVanalysis
3.IRRandpaybackperiodanalysis
4.Analysisofadditionalinformation
5.Recommendation
ComparisonoftheBusinessCases
MostCompellingBusinessCaseMatchMyDollClothingLineExpansion
MatchMyDollClothingLineExpansionisthethemostcompellingopportunity.Thisinitialrecommendationisbasedsolelyonaqualitativecomparisonofthecasesandthefinancialexhibitsprovidedbythebrandmanagers.ASWOT(Strength,Weakness,Opportunity,&Threat)analysiswasusedtoaidthedecisionprocess.SeeTables1&2forSWOTanalysis.
BenefitsoftheMatchMyDollClothingLineExpansion:
*Successoftheoriginallineofbusiness
*Utilizationofthebusinessesexistingstrengths
*LongtermabilityfortheproducttostayuptodateanddrivebusinessConcernsfortheDesignYourOwnDoll:
*Highriskassociatedwithdevelopingaproprietarysoftwaresystem
*Complexityofmanufacturing
*Highbreak-evensalesvolume
OverviewBusinessCase1-MatchMyDollClothingLineExpansion
TheproposalfortheMatchMyDollClothingLineExpansionistoexpandtheline,basedonthesuccessandpopularityoftheexistingproductline,toincludeproductsforallfourseasons.Thecurrentproductincludesadollandtwosetsofmatchingwarmweatherclothingforchildanddoll.SeeTable1forSWOTanalysis.Benefitsoftheexpandedbusinesslineinclude:
*Projectedtobeasprofitableastheexistingline.
*Opportunitiesexistforoff-peakdiscountsinthesupplychainandmanufacturing
*Reductionofseasonalityinsalesandearnings
OverviewBusinessCase2-DesignYourOwnDoll
TheproposalfortheDesignYourOwnDollistocreateanewlineof
Marketresearchwithfocusgroupsindicatesthatgirlswantdollslikethemselves.Thenewbusinesswouldenablecustomersto:
*Participateintheexperienceofcreatingthedoll
*Gotoawebsiteandcustomizethedoll’phsysicalattributes,suchashairandeyecolor
*Selectaccessoriesandclothing
*
Oncethecustomerhascompletedthedesign,thedollismanufacturedandshippedtothecustomer.Abenefitofthenewbusinesslineispremiumpricing.Theintentofthebusinessistocreateanewmarketsegmentarounddesignadoll(designingadoll,ordidyoumeanDesignYourOwnDoll).SeeTable2forSWOTanalysis.
OneofthemaindrawbacksofDesignYourOwnDollisthehighercostsassociatedwiththecustomizationprocess,whichoutweighitsbenefits.Insum,basedonourinitialevaluation,theMatchMyDollExpansionappearstobethemoreattractiveproject.
OverviewFinancialAnalysis
Threescenarioswereanalyzedinordertoviewarangeofpossiblefinancialoutcomes.
1.MatchMyDollClothingLineExpansion(Basescenario)asdescribedintheoperatingprojection
2.DesignYourOwnDoll(Basescenario)asdescribedintheoperatingprojection
3.DesignYourOwnDoll(+AdditionalLaborscenario)
+AdditionalLaborscenario-Thisscenarioisincludedbecausethebrandmanager’sdecisiontoexcludesomeinitiallaborcosts,aswellasongoinglaborcosts,isaconcern.Thebrandmanager’dsecisionappearstobebasedontheassumptionthatinternalresourceswillbeallocatedatnoadditionalcosttosupporttheproject.However,theseresourcesmustbefactoredintoascenarioincasetheassumptionisfalse.Toaccountfortheseadditionallaborcosts,anadditional$435,000isaddedtoyear2010.Thiscostwillgrowat5%peryear,overthecourseoftheproject,toaccountforcostoflivingandsalaryincreases.
NPVAnalysis
Table3-NPVScenarios
DiscountRate|CorporateDiscountRates(Risk)||7.7%(low)|8.4%(med)|9.0%(high)|
MatchMyDollClothingLine(Baseline)|$2,978.59|$2,653.89|
$2,391.58|
DesignYourOwnDoll(Baseline)|$3,836.70|$3,248.91|$2,776.07|
DesignYourOwnDoll(+AdditionalLabor)|$1,319.93|$809.38|
$399.68|
*MatchMyDollClothingLine=ModerateRisk(Declared)
*DesignYourOwnDoll=HighRisk(Assumption)
Comparingonlythebaselinescenariosforthedeclaredandassumedlevelsofrisk,theDesignYourOwnDollproposalshowsthehighestNPV.However,whentheadditionalcostoflaborisfactoredintothecomparison,theNPVofDesignYourOwnDoll+AdditionalLaborisreducedto$399,680.
ComparingthebaselineMatchMyDollClothingLineExpansiontotheDesignYourOwnDoll+AdditionalLaborshowsthatMatchMyDollClothingLinehasapproximately$2.25millionmorevaluethanDesignMyOwnDoll.
IRRAnalysis
Table4IRRSensitivityAnalysis|
|IRR|
RevenueChange|MatchMyDollClothingLine|DesignYourOwnDoll(baseline)|DesignYourOwnDoll(+additionallabor)|
3%|18.24%|14.68%|10.86%|
2%|17.74%|14.28%|10.45%|
1%|17.24%|13.87%|10.04%|
0%|16.74%|13.46%|9.62%|
*1%|16.23%|13.04%|9.20%|
*2%|15.72%|12.62%|8.78%|
*3%|15.21%|12.19%|8.35%|
*4%|14.69%|11.77%|7.91%|
*5%|14.16%|11.33%|7.48%|
*6%|13.63%|10.90%|7.03%|
*Themodelreflectsachangeinrevenuefrom+3%to-6%.RevenueandvariablecostsvarywithrespecttonominalaverageGDP.(Assumption)*SGAcostsareconstant(Assumption)
*Capitalexpendituresareconstant(Assumption)
*NetWorkingCapitalratiosnotmodified(Assumption)
*IRRofNPVisnotusedbecausesensitivityisincludedinthediscountrate(Declared)
TheIRRfortheMatchMyDollClothingLineExpansionexceedsthatofBaselineDesignYourOwnDollandDesignYourOwnDoll+AdditionalLabor.Inadowneconomywithaprojectedreductioninrevenuesof6%,theMatchMyDollClothingLineExpansionoutperformstheothertwoscenarios.SeeGraph2foragraphicalcomparisonoftheIRR.Regardingthesensitivityanalysis,theIRRforDesignYourOwnDoll+AdditionalLaborfallsbelowthehigh-riskdiscountrateof9.0%atrevenuesof-2%.SeeGraphs3foragraphicalviewofthesensitivityanalysis.
PaybackPeriodAnalysis
Paybackperiodforeachofthethreescenarios:
*MatchMyDollClothingLineExpansion(baseline)=8.43years
*DesignYourOwnDoll(baseline)=10.09years
*DesignYourOwnDoll+AdditionalLabor=10.31years
AdditionalInformationRequired
1.WhathasbeenthehistoricalimpactofGDPoncompanyrevenueaswellasonthepreviousMatchMyDollClothingLine?
2.WhatistheimpactofrevenuechangeonfixedexpensesandSGA?
3.Whatchangeswouldbeexpectedincapitalexpendituresduringperiodsofchange?
4.Doesthefirmhavehistoricaldataforinventoryturnoverratios,DaysSalesOutstandingandDaysPayableOutstanding?
5.AretherehiddenlaborcostsnotbeingconsideredintheMatchMyDollClothingLineExpansion,similartotheadditionallaborcostsinDesignYourOwnDoll?
6.WhatlevelofriskisDesignYourOwnDoll?
7.Isachangeinrevenuebetween+3%&-6%valid?
8.RevenueandvariablecostsareadjusteddownproportionatelywithGDP.Isthisvalid?
9.Ishistoricaldataforinventoryturnoverratios,Dayssalesoutstandinganddayspayableoutstandingavailable.
Recommendation
RecommendationMatchMyDollClothingLineExpansion
1.NPVforDesignYourOwnDoll(baseline)isover-statedsinceitomitslaborcosts.
2.NPVforMatchMyDollClothingLineExpansion>NPVforDesignYourOwnDoll+AdditionalLabor(Greaterby$2.25million)
3.IRRforMatchMyDollClothingLineExpansion>IRRforDesignYourOwnDoll(baseline)
4.IRRforDesignYourOwnDoll(baseline)>IRRDesignYourOwnDoll+AdditionalLabor
5.IRRoftheDesignYourOwnDoll(baseline)ismoresensitivetorevenuechangesthantheIRRofMatchMyDollClothingLineExpansion
6.IRRoftheDesignYourOwnDoll+AdditionalLaborismoresensitivetorevenuechangesthantheIRRoftheDesignYourOwnDoll(baseline)
7.IRRofDesignYourOwnDoll+AdditionalLabordropsbelowthehigh-riskdiscountrateof9%ifrevenuesdropby2%
8.PaybackperiodforMatchMyDollClothingLineExpansion 9.SWOTanalysissuggeststhatMatchMyDollClothingLineExpansionismorecompelling. 10. TablesandCharts Table1-SWOT: MatchMyDollClothingLineExpansion Strengths*Currentpopularityandcelebritytrendsallowforpremiumpricingmaintenance.*Businessmodelleveragesthefirm’esxistingoperationalandsalesstrengths.*Riskiscomparabletothatofexistingbusinessline.|Weaknesses*Nomarketresearchconducted.*Salesprojectionbasedonexistingline.*Mustkeeppacewithcurrenttrendstomaintainpremiumpricing;smallwindowofopportunity(duetoficklenature).*Supplychainandmanufacturingutilizationchallengeswithever-changingline.| Opportunities*Expandthemarkettoallfourseasons;*reducetheseasonalityinsalesandearnings.*Leveragethepopularitywithcelebritytrend;opportunitywindowisnow.*Maintainpremiumprices.*Takeadvantageofoff-peakdiscountsfromsuppliersandmanufacturers.|Threats*Othervigorousentrantsorcompetitorsintomarketsegment.*Presumptionofdiscountsofferedbysuppliersandmanufacturers.*Continuedwillingnessforchildrentodressliketheirdolls(childrenmatureatdifferentagesbetweenages3and12years)andtrendsamongchildrenchangeovertime.| Table2-SWOT: DesignYourOwnDoll Strengths*Nichemarket.*Leverageexistingloyalcustomerbase.*C
- 配套讲稿:
如PPT文件的首页显示word图标,表示该PPT已包含配套word讲稿。双击word图标可打开word文档。
- 特殊限制:
部分文档作品中含有的国旗、国徽等图片,仅作为作品整体效果示例展示,禁止商用。设计者仅对作品中独创性部分享有著作权。
- 关 键 词:
- NewHeritageDoll