The relationship between tax and accounting rulesWord文件下载.docx
- 文档编号:21248666
- 上传时间:2023-01-28
- 格式:DOCX
- 页数:12
- 大小:25.30KB
The relationship between tax and accounting rulesWord文件下载.docx
《The relationship between tax and accounting rulesWord文件下载.docx》由会员分享,可在线阅读,更多相关《The relationship between tax and accounting rulesWord文件下载.docx(12页珍藏版)》请在冰豆网上搜索。
CatherineGowthorpe(DepartmentofAccountingandFinancialServices,UniversityofCentralLancashire,Preston,UK)
Abstract:
Tracesthehistoryoftheimpositionofacomprehensivetax‐accountinglinkinSweden,identifyingwaysinwhichprofessionalaccountantshavesoughttocircumventtheimpactofthelinkandconsideringtheeffectofthelinkonthethreebodiesinSwedeninvolvedinformulatingaccountingregulationsandrecommendations.AnalysestherangeofargumentsputforwardintheliteratureinSwedenforandagainstthebindinglink.ReportsoninterviewswithleadingSwedishaccountingpractitionersontheirexperienceandviewsofthelink.
Keywords:
Accounting,Rules,Sweden,Taxation
Type:
Generalreview
Publisher:
MCBUPLtd
Article
Objectives
WhileboththeEuropeanUnionandtheInternationalAccountingStandardsCommitteepursuetheobjectiveofharmonizingnationalaccountingpractices,majordifferencesbetweennationalaccountingapproachesremain.OneimportantdifferenceisbetweencountrieslikeGermany,whereacomprehensivebindinglinkbetweentaxandaccountingrulesisfundamentaltotheaccountingsystem,andcountriesliketheUK,wherethereisnosuchcomprehensivelink,albeittaxinfluencesmaybeanimportantfactorinsomeareasofaccountingpolicychoice.
Swedenoffersusanunusualexampleofacountrytornbetweenthetwoapproaches,withaformallegalaccountingsystembasedonabindingtax‐accountinglinkandaprivate‐sector,standard‐settingbodyseekingtobreakthatlink.Inthisarticlewereportonastudyofthedebateoverthetax‐accountinglinkinSweden,basedonaliteraturereviewandinterviewswithpractitioners.
Thelinkbetweenaccountingandtaxation
Twocountries,GermanyandtheUK,canbeseenasleadingdistinctiveandcontrastingaccountingtraditionsintheEuropeanUnion.Generalaccountingfeaturesofthesetwoaccountingmodelshavebeencharacterizedasfollows(adaptedfrom[1]):
Anglo‐Saxon(includingUK)
∙•
fair;
shareholderorientation;
disclosure;
taxrulesseparate;
substanceoverform;
professionalstandards.
Continental(includingGermany)
legal;
creditororientation;
secrecy;
taxdominated;
formoversubstance;
Governmentrules.
TheEuropeanUnion’sexperienceofattemptingtoachieveharmonizationofaccountingpracticethroughoutthecommunityillustratesthedifficultyofreconcilingthesetwotraditions.Thefirstdraftofthefourthdirectiveoncompanylaw,relatingtotheharmonizationofcompanyaccountingrequirements,wasproducedin1971.ItreflectedtheaccountingtraditionsofFranceandGermanyinbeingbasedonrigidprescription.Following1January1973,whentheUKjoinedtheCommunity,theconcernsoftheaccountancyprofessionweresummarizedbyoneoftheUK’sleadingacademicaccountants:
ThemostimportantfearofBritishaccountantsseemstobethattheDirective,ifimplementedinitspresentform,woulddiscounttheimportancewhichweintheUKattachtothe“trueandfairview”provisionoftheBritishlegislation,whichleavesroomforthenecessaryflexibilityinpreparingandreportinguponcompanyaccounts[2].
UnderpressurefromtheUKGovernmenttheseconddraftofthedirectivewasamendedbothtoincorporatethe“trueandfairview”conceptandtoallowmoreflexibility.AsapartnerinaleadingUKfirmofaccountantsobserved:
Thisisamostimportantchangeinemphasisweakeningasitdoestheoriginalprescriptiveapproachofthefirstdraft[3].
WithinthefourthdirectiveboththeUKandGermanyhavesoughttominimizechangefromtheirtraditionalapproach.Thus,whentheUKGovernmentintroducedlegislationtoimplementthedirective,theministerstatedthathewas“atpainstoimposetheminimumchangenecessaryinactualaccountingpractice”[4].SimilarlyinGermanythepreambletothelegislationimplementingthefourthdirective,alludingtothetrueandfairview,states:
Inspiteofthepretentiousformulationitissupposedthatforpracticetherewillbenoprinciplechanges[5].
Akeydifferencebetweenthetwocountrieshasbeenidentified:
UKaccountingpracticeshavedevelopedseparatelyfromtaxlaw...whereasGermanaccountinghasbeensignificantlyaffectedbytaxrules[6].
InGermanytheMassgeblichkeitsprinzip,translatedasthe“principleofbindingness”(seeforexample[7,pp.8‐9])orthe“principleofcongruency”[8]laysdowntherelationshipbetweentaxandaccountinglaw:
Accountingruleslaiddownbycommerciallawapplytothefinancialaccountsand,providedtheyarenotspecificallycoveredinsomeotherwayintaxlaw,alsoapplytothetaxaccounts.
Wheretaxregulationsofferopportunitiestoreducetaxableincome,thesebenefitsmaybeenjoyedonlyiftheyarerecognizedinthefinancialaccountsaswellasthetaxaccounts,soinpracticefirmswillacceptthesetaxregulationsasaconstraintontheirchoiceofaccountingpolicyinthefinancialaccounts.
Incertainspecialcasesthetaxregulationsmayincreasetaxableincomecomparedtotheprovisionsofcommerciallaw.InthesecasesthetaxregulationsmustapplyinthetaxbalancesheetsothattheMassgeblichkeitsprinziphasnoeffect.
Whatissignificanthereisthatthedominanceoftaxlawoveraccountingpracticeiscomprehensive.IntheAnglo‐Saxontradition,bycontrast,taxfactorsmayinfluencespecificaccountingpolicychoices[9,10],butonlyonapiecemealbasis;
overall,thebasisofcomputationoftaxableincomeandreportedaccountingincomemaydiffersubstantially.
Consequenceswhichfollowonfromacomprehensivetaxaccountinglinkinclude:
Companieswishingtoenjoyspecialtaxallowancesmustreportequivalentexpenditureinthepublishedaccounts,sothatreportedprofitstendtobedepressed.Thus,whenasetofaccountingdatawassenttotheUKandGermantechnicalpartnersofaninternationalaccountingfirm,theestimatedprofitaccordingtoUKpracticewas192millionECU,accordingtoGermanpractice133millionECU[11].ALondoninvestmentanalysthassuggestedthat,onaverage,UKreportedprofitsshouldbereducedbyone‐quartertobecomparablewithGermanfigures“becauseofinventiveaccountantsandahistoryofinflation”[12].
Incountrieswithacomprehensivetax‐accountinglink,thetendencytowardsconservatismwillnotnecessarilyapplyconsistentlyfromyeartoyear.Inyearswhenalossismadeexcessivelyconservativeprovisionsagainstprofitinpreviousyearsmaybewrittenbacktoprofitinordertobenefitfromtaxlosses.Thusan“incomesmoothing”effectarises,wherebyprofitisunderstatedingoodyearsandoverstatedinbadyears.Anexamplewasrevealedin1993whenDaimler‐BenzreportedaprofitofDM615millionbasedonGermanaccountingrulescomparedtoalossofDM1,839millionbasedonUSaccountingrules.Thecontinuedavailabilityoflarge“secretreserves”,arisingfromexcessprovisionsmadefortaxpurposesinpreviousyears,isillustratedbyadifferencebetweenreportedequityonaGermanbasisofDM18,145millionandonaUSbasisofDM26,281millionasattheendof1993[13].
Incountrieswherethereisnotacomprehensivetax‐accountinglinkasystemofprovisionfor“deferredtaxation”isneededtoaccountfortimingdifferencesbetweentherecordingofexpensesfortaxandaccountingpurposes.CountrieswheredeferredtaxationhascausedmajorcontroversyincludetheUK,TheNetherlandsandtheUSA.Bycontrast,incountrieswithatraditionofastrongtax‐accountinglinksuchasGermanyandFrance,nocontroversyhasarisenbecausesuchtimingdifferencesarefewandtrivial(see[14]).
InbothGermanyandtheUKthereseemstobeabroadconsensusamongthoseconcernedwithaccountingtopreservetheirtradition.InGermanythelinkisseenasunderpinningakindofsocialcontract,wherebygeneroustaxallowancesleavecashresourcesavailabletoreinvestinthebusiness,andtheacceptanceofcorrespondinglylowprofitsreducessimilarlytheclaimsofcapitalfordividendsandlabourforwages(see[15]);
indeed,implementationoftheEUdirectivesonaccountinginGermanyappearstohavebeendelayedtoallowtimetodevisewaysofcomplyingwithoutchangingthetax‐accountinglink[16].IntheUKtheaccountingprofessionhasbeensimilarlyattachedtotheirtraditionalapproach,lobbyingvigorously,forexample,tobringtheUK“trueandfairview”requirementintotheEUdirectives[17,pp.84‐5]..
WithinSweden,bycontrast,theissueastowhetheracomprehensivetax‐accountinglinkshouldcontinuehasstimulatedconsiderablecontroversy.Astudyofthatdebate,therefore,boththrowslightontheargumentsforandagainstthetax‐accountinglinkandillustratesthecontrastbetweentheAnglo‐SaxonandtheContinentalaccountingmodels.
AccountingregulationinSweden
In1928theMunicipalIncomeTaxActwaspassed,creatingtheSwedishlinkbetweentaxandaccounting.ItisnotsurprisingthatSwedentookthisroute,giventhatthefirstprofessorsofaccountinginSwedenwereeitherGermanoreducatedinGermany(see[18]).In1929anAccountingActwaspassed,sothatthetax‐accountinglinkwasformedbeforeabasiclegalaccountingframeworkwasputinplace.
Fromthe1960sonwardstheinfluenceoftheleadi
- 配套讲稿:
如PPT文件的首页显示word图标,表示该PPT已包含配套word讲稿。双击word图标可打开word文档。
- 特殊限制:
部分文档作品中含有的国旗、国徽等图片,仅作为作品整体效果示例展示,禁止商用。设计者仅对作品中独创性部分享有著作权。
- 关 键 词:
- The relationship between tax and accounting rules
链接地址:https://www.bdocx.com/doc/21248666.html