英语bp辩论.docx
- 文档编号:1888766
- 上传时间:2022-10-25
- 格式:DOCX
- 页数:6
- 大小:25.65KB
英语bp辩论.docx
《英语bp辩论.docx》由会员分享,可在线阅读,更多相关《英语bp辩论.docx(6页珍藏版)》请在冰豆网上搜索。
1.THBTcooperationbetterthancompetitioninpromotingsocialadvancement.
正:
cooperationisbetterthancompetition
Economicglobalization,
DuringtheAPECsummit,ChinesepresidentXiJinpingandAmericanpresidentBarackObamaannouncedthattheirtwonationswouldworktoreducegreenhousegases.
反:
cooperationisnotbetterthancompetition.
Withoutthecompetitionbetweenthe
2.THWrequirealladvertisersofmedicinesandhealthproductstoprovidescientificevidencefortheirclaims.
正:
medicinesandhealthproducts
反:
advertisers
PMLO
DPMDLO
MGMO
GWOW
DPM:
(Openingremarks:
usingthestepsasshowninPPT)
Mr.speaker,MembersoftheHouse,theleaderofoppositiontodayhastoldusthatcooperationisnotbetterthancoopetitioninpromotingsocialadvancement.
Butwethinkthiswillnotworkwell.Weshould…
Inordertosupportourstance,todayIwillhaveoneextensionandoneargument.Firstly,Iwillprovetheworkabilityofourplan,andtheargumentcaresabout….
Butbeforethat,Iwillgivetworebuttals.
(Substantiation)
(I.Rebuttals)
(repairing-orientatedrebuttal)1…..
(refutation-orientatedrebuttal)2…..
(Extensions)
(Challengingtheburdenofproof)
(Thinkingofnewarguments)
(Conclusions)
Tosumup,todayIhavegiventworebuttals:
Allthosemadeourgovernmentsidebelievethat
DLO:
Mr.Speaker,membersoftheHouse,ladiesandgentlemen:
(Openingremarks)
(Substantiation)
AstheDeputyLeaderofOppositiontoday,Iwouldliketodividemyspeechintothreeparts:
firstIwouldliketogivetworebuttals,afterwardsIwouldliketogivemyargumentsApreviewoftheargumentsshouldbeverylistener-friendly.
andfinallymyconclusion.
(2rebuttals)
Herearemyarguments.
1….
2….
Toconclude,astheDLO,Ihaveclaimedthatmedia’ssupervisoryfunctioncannotbereplacedeasily,andIhaveexplainedwhythispolicy“banningmediacoverage”isunnecessaryandwhythegovernmentwoulddefinitelypayhighpriceifissuingtheban.没有总结第二个argument
Balancingtheadvantagesanddisadvantages,thishousebelievesthatweshouldnotbanmediacoverageofcelebrities’privacy.
GW:
GovernmentWhipSpeech
(Openingremarks-CommentonthePrincipleIssues)
Ladiesandgentlemen,Iregrettosaythatinthislong-lastingdebatewesawanoppositionwhooverlookedtheimportanceofcelebrities‘righttoprivacyandthenecessitiesofprotectingthisprivacy.Theyclaimedthatonceacelebritychosetostepoutintothepublicattention,heautomaticallyagreedtogiveuphisprivacyrighttofulfilltheso-called“publicduty”.Whichis,inotherwords,sinceacelebrityhasgainedsomuchattentionandmoneyfromhiscareer,heshouldthereforebewillingtosacrificehisrighttosatisfymediaandhisfellowcitizensinreturn.Firstly,wedonotthinkitisthecelebrities’publicdutytogiveuphisprivacyright.Rather,itisthecelebrity’sprivacythatismosteasilyharmedandneedtobeprotected.Secondly,webelievebyprotectingthisprivacywecanprotectmorepeoplefrompotentialharmandguidethesocietytowardsabettersocialvalue.Iwillprovethesetwopointsinmyfollowingspeech.
(Refutation)
1.Governmentshouldprovideweapons(allowmediasupervision)insteadoftaking(coverage)rightsaway?
Firstly,coveragerightdoesn’texistifitisaboutpersonalissues(privacy).
Secondly,basedonthisclaim,wecanalsosafelydrawtoaconclusionthatgovernmentshouldcomeupwithpoliciesandlawsasweaponstoprotecttheprivacyrightofcelebrities,notneglectingitsdutyanddeprivethisrightfromthem.Giveacommentofthisargumentasaconclusion:
Sothankyou,memberofopposition,whatyousaidisexactlythesametoourmodel
2.Shouldacelebritypayforhisfamebygivingupprivacy?
No.Whateverhegotfromhiscareerhepaidforthemthroughhishardworkandself-decipline.Asfortheopposition’sconcernthatcelebritiesmayhidedirtylittlesecretsandthereforehavebadinfluenceonpublic,wehavealreadyprovedthatgovernmentwouldsupervisethemwithmoresolidandvalidpoliciesandlaws,andwebelieveonlythegovernmenthassuchauthoritytodoso.
(SummaryModel:
AHRP)
Thoughoutthisdebate,Iseemainlytwoclashes.
Clash1Doesthemediacoverageofcelebrities’privacydosuchharmthatitneedtobebanned?
(YES)
Opposition:
Thesecoverageshelptosupervisecelebrities,teachcitizensrightfromwrongandsendpositivemessagestothepublic.Warrantismissing.加上Theyputmorestressonthebenefitofmediacoverageofcelebrities’privacy.
Us:
Thesecoveragesharmthecelebritiesandtheirfamiliesandfriendsbyaffectingtheirnormaldailylives,sometimesevenarousingpersonalattacksandinsults.(ZGR)
Thesecoveragesharmthefans(esp.teenagerswholookeduptotheirmodels)bymisleadingthemtodothesameth
- 配套讲稿:
如PPT文件的首页显示word图标,表示该PPT已包含配套word讲稿。双击word图标可打开word文档。
- 特殊限制:
部分文档作品中含有的国旗、国徽等图片,仅作为作品整体效果示例展示,禁止商用。设计者仅对作品中独创性部分享有著作权。
- 关 键 词:
- 英语 bp 辩论